Dealing with multiple personal debts might feel a lot like playing whack-a-mole – different bills with different due dates, minimum balances and late fines and penalties. Just when you’ve sent in one payment, another bill pops up. It’s easy to see how people get behind when repaying multiple debts overwhelms them. Debt consolidation can help by essentially rolling all your debt payments, like credit card bills, into one with a single due date and a fixed interest rate that is typically lower, depending on your credit score. Sounds easy right? While debt consolidation does provide a bevy of benefits, it does have its pitfalls if one isn’t careful. But don’t fret, we here at MagnifyMoney got your back! Continue reading our guide on consolidating debt to learn the in’s and out’s of debt consolidation!
Debt Consolidation: Understanding the Basics
As stated above, a key component to debt consolidation is rolling all monthly payments into one. There are two primary ways to concentrate debt payments into one bill: transferring the debt to a 0% balance transfer credit card, or a debt consolidation loan. Your credit score is a big determining factor as to which of the two options you should choose. If you have a credit score of 700 or higher it’s probably better to consider a balance transfer credit card. We will talk move about balance transfers further down. If you have a credit score below 700, which is common with someone dealing with a good amount of credit card debt, a debt consolidation loan is right up your alley. Let’s jump into learning exactly what a debt consolidation loan really is!
Looking to increase your credit score so you can qualify for a balance transfer credit card? — 6 simple steps to improve your credit score!
What is a debt consolidation loan?
A debt consolidation loan is any type of loan that is used to pay off all existing debts, which allows you to focus on just paying one monthly payment opposed to several. (More about this in the section below!) In many cases, debt consolidation loans offer lower interest rates and extended terms compared with your current payments. People typically choose to consolidate debt to simplify their finances or to save money on interest payments. Borrower beware: Upfront fees or temporary terms could eat into that savings. Make sure to read the fine print before committing to your debt consolidation loan! Plus, consolidating debt without a plan to address the behavior that got you into financial trouble in the first place may actually exacerbate your debt if new lines of credit tempt you to start spending again.
How debt consolidation works
When you obtain a debt consolidation loan, you receive a lump sum to pay off your existing debts. Then, instead of juggling multiple payments, you can focus on making the one new loan payment. “You essentially take multiple loans that might be causing confusion with different interest rates and different terms, and roll them into a single loan, which leaves you with one single payment needing to be made,” said Todd R. Tresidder, money coach at FinancialMentor.com. Debt consolidation works best when you have a credit score that allows you to qualify for a loan with interest rates lower than what you’re currently paying. The higher your credit score, the better debt consolidation can work for you.
— If you are dealing with average or poor credit, and want to consolidate your debt.
View our list of debt consolidation loans for fair credit or our list of debt consolidation loans for bad credit
What types of debt can I consolidate?
Debt consolidation can be used to simplify almost any type of unsecured consumer debt. This includes:
“Though debt consolidation is most often used for credit cards, there’s not a boundary line. You could consolidate pretty much any type of loan that you have,” Tresidder said.
Which loans can be used to consolidate debt?
Based on LendingTree data, personal loans are the most popular option for debt consolidation, but a home equity loan or HELOC work as well. There are companies that specialize in debt consolidation loans, or you may choose to work with your preferred local bank or credit union. To make it easier for you, we’ve compiled a list of the best personal loans for debt consolidation.
One caveat: You will need good credit to ensure you’re able to obtain a loan with better rates and terms than your existing debt.
Depending on your unique needs and situation, there are different loan products that can help you consolidate and streamline your debt payments. View our guide on choosing the right debt consolidation method to get a better understanding of the options available for you.
When is debt consolidation a good idea?
Chris Dlugozima, education specialist with GreenPath Financial Wellness, said that debt consolidation is ideal for individuals with a reasonably good credit score who have an isolated reason for having fallen behind on their debts. “A debt consolidation loan can make sense for someone who has identified the cause of why their debt has crept up and has already addressed that. Like, ‘I lost a job, but now I’m back at work.’ Or, ‘I was overspending, but now I’ve had some success following a budget and I’m confident I won’t get back into that situation,’” he said.
Having a good credit score allows more options to be available when deciding to consolidate debt at a lower interest rate. Whether you decide using a personal loan, home equity, or even potentially qualifying for a balance transfer card, your credit score will likely be the biggest determining factor when deciding which option is best.
It may be a necessity for others, a lifeline for those in danger of falling behind on bill payments. “If you’re in a situation where you can’t make your payments at the lower interest rate, and the extended terms allow you to make your payment so you don’t go into default, then that helps as well,” said Tresidder.
When is debt consolidation a bad idea?
A certified credit counselor might recommend a debt-management plan as an alternative to debt consolidation for those with significant debt, or for people who are struggling to address the root cause of their debt.
“If you’ve ever tried to shovel in a blizzard, it might feel like you’re accomplishing something, but are you?” said Dlugozima. Debt consolidation can often feel the same way. “You get a sense of relief that you’ve solved a problem when you maybe haven’t.” When existing debts are paid off with a debt consolidation loan, some consumers may start feeling comfortable and become tempted to let those debts creep back up again, especially with credit cards.
Debt consolidation isn’t an ideal fit for those with below average to poor credit scores. The main benefit of debt consolidation is to roll all debt into a loan with a lower interest rate than what’s currently being paid. Having a below average to poor credit score pretty much nullifies this since you’ll end up with a loan with a sky-high interest rate.
What’s your goal? Debt consolidation may even increase your financial burden if you don’t carefully review an offer. A lower monthly payment might be deceptive if the terms are significantly longer. “A lot of people think only in terms of monthly payments, but you’ve got to look at the total of what you’re paying. You might have a lower interest rate and a longer term, but effectively you’re paying a higher total cost,” Tresidder said.
If you aren’t focused on the end game of becoming debt-free, a debt consolidation loan might not be the best approach for dealing with existing debts. “If you’re just trying to avoid a creditor or shift your pay dates around, that doesn’t solve a problem, it just delays the inevitable,” Sokunbi said. She advised searching online or picking up a book on debt repayment strategies to start you off on the right foot. “They will talk you through the best approach to paying off this now consolidated debt because that’s just Step 1 to getting yourself out of debt.”
– Still unsure of when debt consolidation can be a good or bad idea? View this article
How does debt consolidation affect your credit?
Consolidating debt with a loan can have both positive and negative effects on your credit score. “It’s very nuanced. It depends,” said Dlugozima. “If it’s done in a way that doesn’t allow additional debt to accumulate, it probably won’t immediately affect the credit until the debt gets paid down.”
The negative effects of debt consolidation on your credit score
If you close your accounts as they are paid off, that can be damaging to your score. Older accounts make for a better credit score; closing accounts means that your credit utilization ratio increases as your credit limit decreases, which also negatively impacts your score. On the flip side, if you continue to spend on the accounts you’ve paid off with your loan, your credit score can take a dive. “If you just pay the minimum balance on your debt consolidation loan and go back to those old zero-balance credit cards and start racking up debt, it’s going to negatively impact your credit,” said Sokunbi.
How debt consolidation can improve your credit score
Successfully paying off debt will most certainly have a positive effect on your score in the long term, as large debts and late payments can really bring your score down. “If you’re currently incurring penalties because you can’t make your payments and by consolidating you’re able to make your payments, clearly that’s going to help your credit score over time,” said Tresidder.
— Click here to get a deeper understanding of the effects of debt consolidation on your credit.
Alternative options to pay off debt
A debt consolidation loan is just one approach to consolidating debt. Depending on your unique needs and financial situation, another option might be preferable.
A balance transfer is a popular approach to managing credit card debt. By transferring the balances on existing cards to a new card with a more attractive interest rate, consumers get the mutual benefits of simplified payments and cost savings. Many individuals take advantage of introductory offers of 0% interest for a certain length of time in order to make headway on their debt without the added expense of interest. To qualify for a balance transfer credit card, it’s best to have a good or excellent credit score.
“You have to read the fine print and you have to understand the numbers. If you know you’ll be able to pay off the entire balance before the introductory offer expires, it can save you a significant amount of money,” Sokunbi said. “But once that introductory rate expires, it’s often much higher than where you are coming from.” Some intro 0%-interest credit cards also have severe penalties and rate increases if you miss a payment, so proceed with caution.
It is convenient to shop for a balance transfer credit card online with our list of the best balance transfer credit card offers.
- Potentially an intro 0% interest rate for up to 21 months
- Easy to create a repayment schedule
- Easy to shop for online
- Good or excellent credit recommended
- Attractive rates are often for a limited time only
- May have penalties and rate increases
Recommended balance transfer card:
- Regular APR
- 14.24% - 25.24% Variable
- Intro Purchase APR
- 0% for 6 Months
- Intro BT APR
- 0% for 18 Months
- Rewards Rate
- 5% cash back at different places each quarter like gas stations, grocery stores, restaurants, Amazon.com and more up to the quarterly maximum, each time you activate, 1% unlimited cash back on all other purchases - automatically.
– Learn how to use a balance transfer to attack debt here!
Snowball versus avalanche. If you have the willpower to stick with a DIY debt repayment strategy, a debt snowball or debt avalanche approach might be right for you. With both approaches, you pay the minimum balance each month on all but one debt.
In a debt snowball, you pay all extra money toward the smallest debt until it is paid off and then move on to tackling the next smallest until all of your debts are gone. In a debt avalanche, you pay your debts off in order of their interest rate (highest first), which gives you the lowest mathematical cost of paying off the loan.
“One is focused on cost, but the other gives you the highest emotional satisfaction because you can see those loans getting paid off quicker, which allows you to stick with it better,” said Tresidder. “One is financially the best solution and the other is emotionally the best solution. It’s going to depend on the individual, what they need to stick with the plan.”
>> Enter your debts into our Debt Snowball vs Debt Avalanche calculator to see which method is best for you!
Sticking to a budget is self-satisfying and free of fees. But, you need to be realistic about whether or not you have the determination to stay on task. In many cases, people who are already deeply in debt might not be equipped to make the most responsible financial choices.
- No-cost option
- Emotionally satisfying
- Building good financial habits for the future
- May be difficult to stick with
Debt relief programs
When engaging with a debt settlement company, it is essential to first check their reputation. “You have to be very careful with these companies. They’re one of the top consumer complaints,” Tresidder warned. “But, there are people who have gone down the tube so far they’re completely desperate and this may be their only choice.”
With debt settlement, a company will negotiate your debts with your creditors on your behalf for a fee. Often, you pay the settlement company and they make your payments for you. In the process, they allow some of your accounts to go into default so your creditors will be more motivated to negotiate down the balances. “I would not go with any debt settlement company that tells you to pay them before they have a negotiated deal and before you begin payments directly on the amount,” Tresidder said.
- Offers help for individuals in serious debt trouble
- Provides strict payment schedule
- People who complete the program usually pay-off their unsecured debt in 24 to 48 months. This assumes that they complete the program.
- Better option than filing bankruptcy.
- Some companies in this space may use predatory practices
- Can negatively impact your credit score
- May result in legal ramifications if not done properly
- For some people, depending on their financial situation, they may have to pay tax on amount of debt that was reduced
– Learn more about debt relief in this guide.
If you have time and patience, you can try to negotiate your debt directly with the creditors. If you would like professional help to negotiate your debt on your behalf, then a debt relief company can help. Click here to compare leading debt relief companies.
How to make debt consolidation work for you
When deciding the best way to consolidate your credit card debt, or whether a debt consolidation loan is the right step for you, first consider your financial habits and your commitment to make a change. “A debt consolidation [loan] is putting a Band-Aid on a problem. It’s not a solution. Debt consolidation is merely changing the terms of your loan to create a payment that’s easier for your situation,” Tresidder said.
As part of your debt consolidation efforts, consider speaking with a debt management planner or a credit counselor. “There are a lot of great non-profit ones that are actually there to support you and help you and guide you. When you meet with a legitimate credit counselor, you will have a budget, you will look at your credit report, you will analyze your debt and your options, and you will leave with a detailed written action plan,” said Dlugozima.
Most importantly, do your research. Shop around and find an offer that helps you streamline your payments and saves you money.