The Student Loan Consolidation Hack That Could Save You Thousands

Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone. It may not have been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.

Written By

Updated on Friday, November 13, 2015

Mixed Race Young Female Agonizing Over Financial Calculations in Her Kitchen.

If you’re thinking about consolidating your federal student loans, read this post before taking another step.

It could save you a lot of money.

Why Consolidate?

Before we get into the interest rate hack that could save you thousands of dollars and shave months off your debt repayment period, let’s quickly talk about why you would and wouldn’t consider consolidating your federal student loans.

First, consolidating will not get you a better interest rate. You might get a better interest rate if you refinance with a private loan, but that’s a separate topic. When you consolidate, you end up with a weighted average interest rate of all the loans in the consolidation and not just slashing to the lowest possible rate.

The main reason to consolidate is to qualify for income-driven repayment plans. Certain federal student loans disbursed before July 1, 2010 (called FFEL loans) aren’t eligible, but you can make them eligible through consolidation. That can be a big benefit.

You might also consider consolidating if you have variable rate loans and you want to lock in a low fixed rate.

If you’re in one of those two situations, consolidating could make a lot of sense. And there’s a strategy you can use that might save you a lot of money.

[Federal Direct Consolidation Loan Review]

Meet Hailey

To show you how this works, we’re going to talk about a fictitious person named Hailey.

Hailey is single, living in New York, and makes $50,000 per year. She’s also dealing with the following two federal student loans:

Loan #1

  • $20,000 balance
  • 5.6% interest rate

Loan #2

  • $40,000 balance
  • 8.5% interest rate

Hailey can afford to put $500 per month towards her student loans right now, which is enough to cover the minimum payments with an extra $75 to spare.

But she’s a little uncertain about her job prospects over the coming years and she’d like to apply for income-driven repayment just in case she needs it.

The problem is that both of her loans are FFEL loans and therefore aren’t eligible for income-driven repayment. Which is why consolidating makes a lot of sense for her.

So how should she do it? Let’s look at the normal way most people would do it, and how she could save herself a lot of money doing it differently.

[Pay Off Student Loans or Invest — Which is Right for You?]

The Wrong Way to Consolidate

Most people would assume that Hailey should consolidate her two loans into a single loan.

If she did that, she would end up with a single $60,000 loan with a 7.63% interest rate (the interest rate is actually rounded up to the nearest 1/8 percent during consolidation).

Using the repayment estimator, her standard monthly payment would be $424, with the option of paying as little as $270 under the Pay As You Earn repayment plan.

But remember, Hailey can afford to put $500 per month towards her student loans right now. Using this debt snowball calculator, and assuming that she pays $500 every month for the life of the loan, here is the result:

  • The loan would be paid off in 228 months (19 years exactly).
  • She would pay $53,572.99 in interest over the life of the loan.

Luckily for Hailey, there’s a simple way she could save a lot of money without paying any more each month.

The Right Way to Consolidate

You may not know this, but you don’t have to consolidate all of your loans together.

You can actually consolidate a single loan all by itself. And with two loans, you have the option of doing two different consolidations.

If Hailey did this, she would end up with two loans with the same balances and interest rates as before.

However, they would now be federal consolidation loans and therefore eligible for income-driven repayment.

And doing it this way would end up saving Hailey a lot of money.

Because now her extra payments could go towards the loan with the 8.5% interest rate instead of a loan with a 7.63% interest rate, which would have been the case if she had consolidated them together.

And remember, directing extra payments towards your highest interest rate loans is the most efficient way to pay off your debt. So by preserving that higher interest rate, she’s allowed herself to get a better return on every single extra payment she makes.

Assuming she makes the same $500 monthly payment as above and applies the extra payments to the 8.5% loan first, here are the results:

  • The loan would be paid off in 218 months.
  • She would pay $48,909.94 in interest over the life of the loan.

In other words, with the exact same monthly payment she would save herself $4,663 in interest and be debt-free 10 months sooner.

Not bad!

[How Student Loans Affect Your Credit Score]

Are There Downsides to This Strategy?

Obviously this strategy can save you a lot of money, but are there any ways it could potentially backfire?

The short answer is, not really.

It takes a little more work to perform two consolidations instead of one.

And in order to make sure your extra payments are directed correctly, you should send a letter to your servicer letting them know exactly what you want them to do.

But other than that, there’s really nothing to worry about here.

Save Away

The moral of the story is this: if you’re consolidating your federal student loans, doing separate consolidations for loans with significantly different interest rates could save you thousands of dollars and shave months off your debt repayment period.

Customize Your Student Loan Offers with MagnifyMoney Comparison Tool

Advertiser Disclosure: The products that appear on this site may be from companies from which MagnifyMoney receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). MagnifyMoney does not include all financial institutions or all products offered available in the marketplace.

Do you have a question?