When Should You Stop Contributing to Your 401(k) Plan?

Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone and is not intended to be a source of investment advice. It has not been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.

Written By

Updated on Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Unexpected personal expenses can disrupt your budget, and too much credit card spending can push your debt balance into the red — at times like these, you might consider pausing contributions to your 401(k). Although saving for retirement should always be one of your core financial goals, there are times when you may need to stop contributing to your 401(k) retirement plan. Read on, and we’ll review them all.

When your employer doesn’t offer matching 401(k) contributions

One of the biggest benefits offered by the 401(k) is matching contributions. With matching contributions, your employer matches the money you deposit in your 401(k) dollar-for-dollar, up to a certain threshold. This helps turbocharge your retirement savings at no extra cost to you.

However, not all employers offer matching contributions. You can still contribute to your 401(k) even if your employer doesn’t offer a match, but a lack of matching contributions might make you consider other retirement savings options, such as an individual retirement account (IRA), depending on your savings goals.

When your 401(k) fees are too high

If your employer doesn’t offer matching contributions, a good way to gauge whether the 401(k) plan is a good choice for your retirement savings is to look at the fees. If the fees charged by your employer’s 401(k) plan are higher than you like, consider other retirement savings options.

Fees charged by 401(k) plans fall into three broad categories: investment fees, 12b-1 fees and administrative fees.

  • Investment fees: These fees cover the cost of managing the investments and are disclosed in mutual fund or ETF prospectuses. Some funds charge a load fee, which is an industry term for a sales charge or commission. This can be charged up front, in which case it is called a front-end load. Or, it may be paid when the shares are sold, known as a back-end load or redemption fee.
  • 12b-1 fees: This is a type of investment fee, named after the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) rule requiring its disclosure. This fee covers a mutual fund’s marketing and distribution costs, and broker commissions. Some mutual funds charge a 12b-1 fee in place of a load fee.
  • Administrative and service fees: Typically charged as flat fees, these cover the costs of administering the plan, or special add-on costs for 401(k) loans or hardship withdrawals. Administrative fees run to a few hundred dollars per participant, per year. They may not always be disclosed.

Total fees charged on your 401(k) can range from 10 basis points to 2% to 3%. You pay the plan administrator these fees out of your investment balance, and while a few percentage points a year may not sound like much, these fees add up over the life of your 401(k).

Imagine a 29-year-old investor who contributes $19,500 per year to her company’s 401(k) and plans to retire at age 65. Her current 401(k) balance is $100,000, and fees are 3%. Just by switching to a plan that cuts fees in half, to 1.5%, she could save $845,569 by the time she retires. Instead of having $1.9 million upon retirement, she could have more than $2.7 million.

Check out the fee calculator we used to find out just how much your fees are costing you
Remember, even if your 401(k) has high fees, an employer match is still worth considering. Many times, the match will more than cover the fees.

When you have too much debt

While it’s always possible to both pay down debt and make 401(k) contributions, large debt loads charging high interest rates may require more budgetary attention. Very high APRs from your credit card issuers or a debt-to-income ratio that’s too high may mean you should prioritize paying off debt ahead of saving for retirement.

The key thing to consider is how much you’re paying in interest on your debt compared to the returns you’re getting on your investments. If you’re paying an APR of 15% to 20% to a credit card company but you’re only seeing an annual return of 5% to 8% on your 401(k) investments, you may be losing money. That said, pausing contributions to accelerate your debt payoff means you’ll need to play catch-up on your retirement savings later.

When your expenses are too high

Sometimes life gets in the way of your financial goals, especially when emergency spending disrupts your budget. We always advise our readers to build a healthy emergency fund to be prepared for large, unexpected costs or major medical emergencies, but if your fund is low or non-existent, it might be time to hit pause on your 401(k) contributions.

Think hard about expenses that are high enough to make you consider pausing your 401(k) contributions. Can you meet them by cutting out other spending, or refining your budget? Our rule of thumb for when to dip into your emergency fund holds good here as well: Ask yourself whether the expenses are unplanned and uncontrollable. Only true emergencies that are both unplanned and uncontrollable should require you to stop contributing to your 401(k).

When you retire from your job

The ultimate end point to your 401(k) contributions is when you stop working. Remember, 401(k) plans are sponsored by your employer, so when you retire and stop working, your days of making contributions to your 401(k) plan are over. However, this may not be the end of your retirement savings journey.

What happens when you stop contributing to your 401(k)?

Halting 401(k) contributions might be financially necessary, but you should keep in mind what you’re giving up in exchange.

  • You stop reducing your taxable income. Your 401(k) contributions are made with pre-tax dollars from your salary, lowering your taxable income. This can either bump up your refund or lessen what you owe. If you aren’t making contributions, you don’t have the opportunity to reduce your taxable income. This might mean your tax return won’t be as high next year or you could end up owing money.
  • You could miss out on employer 401(k) matching contributions. If your employer makes matching 401(k) contributions, you’re missing out on the extra 401(k) pay bump. Regardless of how much or little your employer contributes, you won’t get to take advantage of the money from matching contributions.

Keep saving when you stop contributing to your 401(k)

If you stop contributing to your 401(k), that doesn’t mean you should stop saving altogether. Keep saving in these other accounts if you have the money to spare:

  • High-yield savings account: If you want to put money away but still have access to it right away, try a high-yield savings account. APYs for these types of accounts are much higher compared to regular savings accounts: sometimes as high as 2.00% versus 0.10%, respectively. This type of account is good for building up an emergency fund or other types of savings that you can immediately tap into.
  • Certificate of deposit (CD): If you have the chance to allow savings to grow for a set amount of time, try a CD. You’ll deposit your funds into an account but won’t have access to it for a set term — sometimes six months, sometimes two years. In that time, you could earn a higher yield compared to a regular savings account or high-yield savings account, depending on the amount you deposit and where you make your deposit.
  • Taxable investment account: If you want to try out investing and have some extra cash to do so, try an investment account. A brokerage account is good for hands-on investors, while a robo-advisor is a good fit for hands-off investors or those who don’t have the time or knowledge to buy individual securities.
  • Individual retirement account (IRA): Whether you go the traditional or Roth IRA route, you can put money away into a personal retirement account that isn’t tied to your job. While the contribution limit for IRAs is lower than it is for 401(k)s, you can still put money away for retirement without using your employer-sponsored plan. This is also a good idea if you eventually leave your job (or lose your job) and need to transfer funds from your 401(k) into an IRA.

Advertiser Disclosure: The products that appear on this site may be from companies from which MagnifyMoney receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). MagnifyMoney does not include all financial institutions or all products offered available in the marketplace.

Do you have a question?