Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone. It may not have been previewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners.
Updated on Wednesday, August 22, 2018
Although an increasing number of states has passed laws to protect consumers by capping interest rates on payday loans, lenders have found creative ways to get around those regulations and issue loans with sky-high rates.
“We see payday lenders utilizing schemes just to get out from as many kinds of restrictions as they can,” said Diane Standaert, director of state policy at the Center for Responsible Lending, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization focused on consumer lending.
Here are three common strategies lenders use to exploit loopholes:
1. They’ve pivoted toward high-cost installment loans instead
One way lenders bypass federal regulations is by offering installment loans instead of the usual, lump-sum payday loans. Unlike traditional payday loans, which borrowers have to repay in full on their next paydays, an installment loan gives borrowers a fixed payment schedule that enables them to repay their debt over time.
Many small-dollar, installment loans come in the form of personal loans. Personal loans are generally perceived as less risky because the borrower knows exactly what their monthly payment is and the rates are fixed, meaning they never change. But just because it’s called an installment loan doesn’t mean it’s any cheaper than a regular payday loan.
A 2016 CFPB study found the average amount of these “payday installment loans” is $1,291 and their APRs range from a staggering 197% to 369%. Installment loan terms vary from a few weeks to several years.
Alex Horowitz, researcher for the consumer finance project at The Pew Charitable Trusts, pointed out that the transition from single-payment loans to multi-payment loans is driven in part by regulatory scrutiny, but also by consumer preference because borrowers want more time to repay. What’s good for borrowers is even better for lenders — and they can make very high profits from these loans.
“There are extreme examples on the market where a $300 or $500 loan can last for 18 months, which is far too long,” Horowitz said. “And if a borrower has it out for even half that time, they would repay several times what was borrowed.”
Although some states have cracked down on payday loans, they are far more lenient with high-cost installment loans. In Delaware, for example, lenders can issue borrowers only five payday loans per year. After that, Horowitz said lenders could switch to offering less-than-60-day installment loans, which aren’t subject to the same annual limit.
California bars lenders from issuing payday loans of $300 or more with terms of less than one month. And lenders’ costs for the loan are limited to $45 per pay period. But lenders can issue installment loans of more than $2,500 in California — without interest rate caps.
Standaert said more than half the loans in the California short-term lending market carry interest rates in excess of 100%, and many California lenders make loans of more than $2,500.
RISE, an online lender that provides consumers with short-term installment loans and lines of credit, offers California loans between $2,600 and $5,000. As of August 17, 2018, a $2,600 loan with a 16-month term has a whopping 224.35% APR.
Standaert said over the last two to three years, payday lenders have been making a push all over the country to try to legalize the longer-term payday loan. So far, 10 states have rejected such proposals.
2. Lenders operate as loan brokers
In Ohio and Texas lenders bypass state interest rate caps by acting as credit service organizations instead of direct lenders. A CSO basically refers borrowers to loans from third-party lenders. And that lender can tack on a sky-high CSO fee to your loan.
“That credit service organization is really not providing any value,” said Christopher Peterson, director of financial services and senior fellow at the Consumer Federation of America. “What’s really happening is that businesses exploit a loophole to generate effectively very high-interest rates; they are just doing it through a cocktail of broker fees and interest rates together.”
Take Ohio, for example. In 2008, the state passed the Short Term Loan Act, which caps the maximum short-term loan amount at $500 and the APR at 28%. But lenders can simply become licensed CSOs, which enables them to charge an additional fee to make up for the lost interest revenue.
In Ohio, RISE currently charges a CSO fee of $917.56 on a $1,000 loan — resulting in an effective APR of 299%. And LendUp, another online lender, charges a CSO fee of between $20 and $25 per $100 to borrowers in Ohio. But Ohio lawmakers have made efforts to close this loophole: In July 2018, Gov. John Kasich signed a bipartisan bill into law to restrict short-term loans.
Under current Ohio state law, CSOs are barred from selling, providing or brokering any loan that is less than $5,000 with an APR higher than 28% — or a loan with a term shorter than a year. The law increases the maximum short-term loan amount to $1,000 from $500, but limits loan terms to 12 months and caps the cost of the loan to 60% of the original principal.
The new rules will go into effect in May 2019. Horowitz said the act will provide lower-cost direct lending to Ohio borrowers, whose cost will be three to four times lower than the state’s current CSO rate. Standaert said that although the new law is an improvement on the current market, it still leaves borrowers exposed to high-cost direct loans because it legalizes a number of charges, including monthly maintenance, loan origination and check collection fees. This can send APRs through the roof, even with the CSO loophole is closed.
More than 3,000 CSOs operate in Texas, which is why it’s called the “Wild West” of payday lending. According to Texas Faith for Fair Lending, a grassroots consumer advocacy group, more than 98% of registered CSOs in this state are payday and auto title lenders.
3. Lenders issue lines of credit instead
Some states have a payday lending statute in place that sets interest rate caps but not for other types of loans, such as a line of credit.
A line of credit works like a credit card, only at a much higher price point. The lender allows you to borrow money up to your line’s limit and charges interest when you draw on the money. Once you repay the funds you borrower, that money is available for you to use again.
Horowitz said lenders in Rhode Island, Virginia and Kansas can charge more in fees and interest by issuing lines of credit instead of payday lending statutes. CashNetUSA, a major online payday lender, charges a 15% transaction fee in Virginia and Kansas when you draw on your credit line on top of the 299% APR, which makes the effective APR much higher.
Smart ways to shop for short-term loans
There’s no getting around the fact that consumers rely on short-term installment loans to fill gaps in financing when they don’t have better alternatives. Although it’s a good sign that many states have capped rates on payday loans, it’s clear that payday loan alternatives can be just as expensive — if not more. It is crucial for consumers to be savvy about which types of loans they choose and compare several options to get their best deal available.
Start with your local credit union or community bank
Many community banks and credit unions offer small-dollar loans at much lower interest rates than you’ll get with a payday or payday installment loan.
For example, all federal credit union loans have an 18% interest cap, except for the Payday Alternative Loans, which are capped at 28%. In addition, these financial institutions are much better regulated than the high-cost lenders.
Shop around and compare
Ideally, you want to look for a fixed-rate loan with an APR of 36% or less. At LendingTree you can shop and compare offers from multiple lenders at once. Fill out a short online form and you can be matched with offers from up to five personal loan lenders. If you’d rather shop by visiting lenders online directly, see if they offer a prequalification tool that will enable you to check your rate and determine if you can prequalify without requiring a hard credit pull.
As low as 3.49%
Minimum 500 FICO®
24 to 60
LendingTree is not a lender. LendingTree is unique in that you may be able to compare up to five personal loan offers within minutes. Everything is done online and you may be pre-qualified by lenders without impacting your credit score. Terms Apply. NMLS #1136.
As of 17-May-19, LendingTree Personal Loan consumers were seeing match rates as low as 3.49% (3.49% APR) on a $10,000 loan amount for a term of three (3) years. Rates and APRs were based on a self-identified credit score of 700 or higher, zero down payment, origination fees of $0 to $100 (depending on loan amount and term selected). Terms Apply. NMLS #1136