Investing

Best Online Brokerage Accounts in September 2022

Editorial Note: The content of this article is based on the author’s opinions and recommendations alone and is not intended to be a source of investment advice. It may not have not been reviewed, commissioned or otherwise endorsed by any of our network partners or the Investment company.
How MagnifyMoney Gets Paid ?
Advertiser Disclosure

With more than 246 online stock brokers to choose from, you might feel overwhelmed as you search for the best online brokerage account for your investing goals.

Here’s the bottom line: This isn’t a search you have to make alone. The MagnifyMoney team dug into the functionality, features and other factors for fourteen of the best online brokers and broke our findings down into the best for each investor type.

For September 2022, we’ve selected Charles Schwab as our best overall online stock broker. And here’s the best part: All of our picks for the best brokerage accounts have no investment minimums so you can start trading with a dollar amount that suits your budget today.

Why trust us: MagnifyMoney is an independent, advertising-supported service that compares financial services and the companies that perform those services. Our editorial independence allows us to make objective selections. Companies cannot pay to be featured higher or lower on our “Best Of” lists, either. Be sure to check out the criteria we used to evaluate each online stock broker on this list.

Best online stock brokers in September 2022

Best forBrokerAccount minimumTrading fees
Overall online stock tradingCharles Schwab$0$0 stock and exchange-traded fund (ETF) trades, $0.65 per options contract
BeginnersTD Ameritrade$0$0 stock and ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract
High-volume tradingtastyworks$0$0 stock trades, $1.00 per options contract, $1.25 per futures contract
Robo-advisor servicesCharles Schwab$0 for brokerage account, $5,000 for robo-advisor services$0 stock and ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract; $0 for automated robo-advisor trades
Retirement investingVanguard$0 $0 stock, ETF and Vanguard mutual fund trades, $1.00 per options contract
Low costsFirstrade$0$0 stock, ETF, option and mutual fund trades
CryptocurrencyWebull$0$0 for stock, option, ETF and cryptocurrency trades

Best for overall online stock trading: Charles Schwab

Account minimum$0
Trading fees $0 stock and ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract
See Details

on Charles Schwab’s secure website

Pros Cons
  • Commission-free trades
  • Multiple education and analysis resources
  • Robo-advisor options with Intelligent Portfolios
  • Wide range of available securities 
  • Socially responsible investing options 
  • Higher futures trading costs than some competitors
  • Partner financial advisors have high minimums

Why we chose it:

Charles Schwab made the top of our list of the best online stock brokers because of the full range of its offerings, including a robo-advisor option and access to financial professionals. As one of the largest online brokers, you’ll gain access to valuable tools that large firms like Schwab can offer, like market research and analysis, too.

Simply put, Schwab offers the best experience to the widest range of potential investors. Some investors may not find their active trading capabilities to be as robust as those offered by other brokers, and others may find that Schwab is missing an asset class or two that other brokers have (like cryptocurrency). But most investors will find their needs well met by Schwab.

Schwab recently acquired TD Ameritrade and began the process of transitioning some of the standout services from that brokerage — including the much-lauded thinkorswim trading platform. TD Ameritrade has extensive educational resources for investors, and Schwab has begun using some of that information through their brokerage as well. Now that the two brokers have joined forces, either would be a solid choice for best overall, but Schwab seems better positioned moving forward given that they’ve acquired TD Ameritrade and not the other way around.

Best for beginners: TD Ameritrade

Account minimum$0
Trading fees $0 stock and ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract
See Details

on TD Ameritrade’s secure website

Pros Cons
  • Intuitive trading platform (thinkorswim) 
  • Extensive educational resources and tools 
  • Countless investment options, including IPOs 
  • Retirement accounts
  • Can't trade fractional shares 
  • $75 fee for all outgoing transfers 

Why we chose it:

TD Ameritrade is known for its depth of educational resources, making it a great option for beginners who are looking to invest through a broker for the first time. There are guided lessons, explainer articles, multimedia such as podcasts, webcasts and other videos, as well as guidance for retirement planning. As mentioned earlier, TD Ameritrade has been recently acquired by Charles Schwab and they are in the process of transitioning into one company. But for the time being, clients can expect business-as-usual services.

The award-winning thinkorswim trading platform has robust features for seasoned investors, but TD Ameritrade provides a comprehensive manual and other training tools to help beginners get up to speed quickly. There are also web-based and mobile app platforms that offer a simpler, more streamlined look at your portfolio and assets. TD Ameritrade also can facilitate relationships with partner financial advisors and offers options for automated investing.

Other brokerages offer educational resources and paper trading platforms as well, but TD Ameritrade has the most resources for those who are just getting started on their investment journey. As you grow more comfortable with the investing world, you’ll have the option to trade securities like foreign currencies, futures contracts, annuities and IPO offerings, which aren’t available through all brokers.

Best for high-volume trading: tastyworks

Account minimum$0
Trading fees$0 stock trades, $1.00 per options contract, $1.25 per futures contract
Pros Cons
  • Commission-free trades
  • Extensive educational and analysis resources
  • Cryptocurrency access
  • Poorly rated mobile applications 
  • Limited securities selection 
  • Per-trade fees can be higher than average

Why we chose it:

Some investors are active day traders who rapidly buy and sell securities to turn a quick profit. Several platforms, including tastyworks, were designed with those investors in mind and tailor their services accordingly. tastyworks is a broker affiliated with tastytrade, a media network for retail options traders, and was built for active traders. You won’t find bond funds or fixed-income securities on tastyworks, but you will be able to swap more esoteric derivatives.

Between its solid online trading platform and the ability to trade plenty of options, active traders will have their needs met with tastytrade. Granted, there are some weaknesses (notably the poor ratings on their mobile applications, which could be a big deal to some traders) and costs for options contracts and futures contracts that are higher than other brokers (but have lower fee caps at higher volume).

What truly sets tastyworks apart is the educational resources, news and analysis that’s specifically designed for active traders through tastytrade. There’s an active community of investors, a full media channel’s worth of content, educational courses and plenty of market analysis. TradeStation, another platform for active traders, doesn’t have those kinds of resources.

Best for robo-advisor services: Charles Schwab

Account minimum$0
Trading fees $0 stock and ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract; $0 for automated robo-advisor trades
See Details

on Robo-advisor Services Charles Schwab’s secure website

Pros Cons
  • Multiple education and analysis resources

  • Access to some financial planning services
  • $5,000 investment minimum

Why we chose it:

Charles Schwab is a longtime standout among brokerages, and its robo-advisor — called Schwab Intelligent Portfolios — is a strong choice for those who wish to place some or all of their funds in an automated investing service. There’s a reasonable minimum opening deposit ($5,000) and Schwab professionals select the ETFs that comprise Intelligent Portfolios. You’ll take a questionnaire to establish your investment goals, risk tolerance and retirement timeline and the robo-advisor will take care of your portfolio.

There’s plenty to like about Charles Schwab beyond its robo-advisor platform, which is why it was selected as the best overall broker — and many investors who use its brokerage services may never use Intelligent Portfolios. There are starter kits for newer investors and deep third-party research for more experienced traders. Some financial planning services are accessible, but other Schwab investment advisory services — like Schwab Private Client and Schwab Advisor Network — have high minimums.

MagnifyMoney compiled a list of the best robo-advisors and chose Betterment as the best overall robo-advisor. Charles Schwab was selected as the best robo-advisor for low fees. Betterment isn’t a true brokerage account, as you’re not able to place self-directed trades on the platform, so it wasn’t eligible for this list of best online brokers.

Best for retirement investing: Vanguard

Account minimum$1,000 for Vanguard Target Retirement Funds and Vanguard STAR® Funds; $3,000 for most other Vanguard funds
Trading fees $0 stock, ETF and Vanguard mutual fund trades, $1.00 per options contract
See Details

on Vanguard’s secure website

Pros Cons
  • Wide range of retirement account options
  • Low costs on Vanguard mutual funds
  • Access to a robo-advisor and personal advisors
  • No access to futures trading 
  • $20 annual maintenance fee (can be waived) 
  • No cryptocurrency 

Why we chose it:

Vanguard is a broker that works with personal investors, retirement plan participants and institutional investors. The latter two tend to have safer, more stable investing strategies, and Vanguard’s built that way for personal investors and retail traders too. There are a lot of proprietary, broad index mutual funds with low expense ratios designed for buy-and-hold, long-term investing through the broker.

In addition to their brokerage services, Vanguard offers individual retirement accounts (IRAs) and other tax-advantaged accounts like 529 plans. You can also choose from a solid selection of bond funds and open certificates of deposit (CDs) through Vanguard. Their robo-advisor service, Vanguard Digital Advisor, integrates with brokerage accounts, and there’s access to fiduciary Vanguard financial advisors if you meet the $50,000 minimum.

If you intend to actively trade stocks or place volume trades, other brokers might be a better option. Vanguard is a strong choice if you intend to buy into the market, hold your assets for a while and maximize your long-term returns.

Best for low costs: Firstrade

Account minimum$0
Trading fees $0 stock, ETF, option and mutual fund trades
See Details

on Firstrade’s secure website

Pros Cons
  • Commission-free trades, $0 options contracts 
  • Strong mobile app ratings
  • Wide range of mutual funds 
  • $55 fee for partial transfer out, $75 for full transfer 
  • No advisory services available 
  • No cryptocurrency 

Why we chose it:

Firstrade launched as a discount broker back in 1985 and has been an online broker since 1997. Unlike most brokerages, Firstrade doesn’t charge a fee on options contracts, and all mutual funds are free through the brokerage. There are no account minimum requirements or maintenance fees, but beware of the automated customer account transfer (ACAT) fees — they’re pretty typical for brokers, but they can be an unpleasant surprise when you transfer money out of your account.

There are some areas where Firstrade falls short relative to other brokers. Larger brokers tend to offer more educational resources and market analysis, though there are some available through Firstrade. Not all asset classes are available, including forex and cryptocurrency. There’s no robo-advisor service on Firstrade, and they’re not partnered with any financial advisors. But if you’re looking for a discount broker who allows you to place trades at the lowest possible cost, Firstrade is a strong choice.

Best for cryptocurrency: Webull brokerage account

Account minimum$0
Trading fees $0 commissions for stock, option, ETF and cryptocurrency trades
See Details

on Webull Brokerage Account’s secure website

Pros Cons
  • Access to more than 25 coins 
  • Fee-free trades
  • Strong mobile app 
  • Practice platform for no-risk trading
  • Limited securities selection 
  • No educational resources for beginners 

Why we chose it:

Among brokerages that offer comprehensive cryptocurrency trading services, Webull brokerage account has the best combination of available coins and low costs. In addition to common cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Etherium, Webull brokerage account allows you to trade a few dozen other coins. There are no fees or commissions for cryptocurrency trading, but there is a 100-point basis spread on either side of a trade (meaning there’s a 1% difference between the buy and sell price). Notably, Webull brokerage account does not permit you to transfer coins in or out of your Webull brokerage account account.

Beyond cryptocurrency trading, Webull brokerage account has a relatively limited selection of available securities on its platform. Investors can trade stocks, ETFs and options, but there’s not much beyond that: they can’t trade mutual funds, bonds, foreign currencies or derivatives like futures. There also isn’t much educational support for newer investors on Webull brokerage account, although there is a paper trading platform for practicing trading strategies.

Ultimately Webull brokerage account is a strong choice for dedicated cryptocurrency traders — there are more available coins than Robinhood and a better user experience than tastyworks. There are some drawbacks though, and you might want to choose a different broker if you are interested in buying mutual funds or other securities that aren’t available on Webull brokerage account.

Other online stock brokers we considered

  • Interactive Brokers: A full-service online broker with features for high net worth individuals, Interactive Brokers (IBKR) is a solid all-around platform with deep research and analysis capabilities.
  • Fidelity: Fidelity is a large brokerage firm with plenty of securities available to trade, including proprietary mutual funds and a low-cost robo-advisor. They also have a partner registered investment advisor (RIA) firm.
  • E*TRADE: Because of its emphasis on low fees (including $0 stock, ETF and options contracts) E*TRADE is a solid choice for investors looking to keep costs low while still using a broker with extensive resources.
  • SoFi : A lender first and foremost, SoFi also offers online brokerage services, although they don’t provide access to mutual funds and some other securities. They do offer a range of deposit accounts for those who’d like to keep their financial services with one company.
  • Merrill Edge: Merrill Edge is owned by Bank of America. There are wealth management services through Merrill Lynch, but brokerage accounts open up access to Merrill Edge’s guided investing services, which have just a $1,000 minimum.
  • Ally Invest: A relative newcomer in the banking space, Ally is a full-service online bank that also provides brokerage services through Ally Invest. There are automated investing services through the platform as well.
  • TradeStation: TradeStation is designed for high-volume day trading, offering a robust trading platform and financial products that include not only stocks and index funds but futures trading and cryptocurrency.
  • Robinhood: A popular, app-based investing platform among millennials, Robinhood offers fewer cryptocurrency options than some competitors but also has relatively lower costs for margin trading.

Frequently asked questions

MagnifyMoney’s selection for best overall online broker is Charles Schwab, which recently acquired TD Ameritrade, another standout brokerage.
An online brokerage account is a service offered by a broker that allows retail investors to place trade orders on exchanges through the internet and hold assets like stocks, bonds and ETFs.
If you participate in a direct stock purchase plan or dividend reinvestment plan through a company, you can avoid using an online broker, but you’ll need one for most kinds of trades.

 

How we chose the best online brokers

MagnifyMoney reviewed 15 of the most well-known online stock brokers based on multiple factors that matter most to investors like you, including:

  • Trading fees, additional fees like ACAT fees and commissions
  • Available securities, such as proprietary mutual funds and ETFs, cryptocurrency and derivatives
  • Advisory services, including robo-advisors and licensed financial advisors
  • Educational resources, simulated investing platforms and other investor resources
  • Mobile trading apps and online brokerage platforms

Criteria like those listed above have an impact on how much you’ll pay to use a platform and how much those costs can ultimately impact your returns. All the online stock brokers we ultimately included on this list are accessible to the average investor and allow self-directed trading, too.

The “Find a Financial Advisor” links contained in this article will direct you to webpages devoted to MagnifyMoney Advisor (“MMA”). After completing a brief questionnaire, you will be matched with certain financial advisers who participate in MMA’s referral program, which may or may not include the investment advisers discussed.

Find a Financial Advisor near you

We will use this information to find the right advisor near you